Creating Duluth-Themed Art with AI - Perfect Duluth Day

Creating Duluth-Themed Art with AI

A Van Gogh style painting of a 1920s cargo train traveling on a winter night though an evergreen forest next to a huge blue lake with the aurora borealis in the night sky.

DALL-E is an online tool that uses machine learning to generate digital images from plain English text descriptions. You type a description of something real or imaginary and the program does its best to create a unique image based on that description. After some time on a waitlist, I recently received an invite that allows me to create and download a limited number of artificial intelligence generated images per month. This came at a good time, as I recently found a watercolor print of the Duluth hillside in a Lincoln Park shop that I liked quite a bit but could not afford. I decided to use some of my AI image credits to see if I could get the automated system to produce Duluth art of at least somewhat comparable quality. In the examples that follow, I describe this process, showing what worked and what did not. The captions of each picture show the text query that generated the image.

Trying to get the program to produce specific architecture or just asking for the image to be set in Duluth did not work very well, as the program blends elements of its source images. This means that trying to add a specific Duluth landmark results in an image that seems a bit off. Or In the case of the image below of a family in front of the Aerial Lift Bridge, very off and a little terrifying.

A faded 1970s photograph of a family smiling on a long concrete pier in front of a large metal lift bridge as a sailboat passes under the bridge.

After a few unsuccessful attempts of trying to get Duluth images by including the word Duluth or well-known Duluth places in the query, I started trying to break Duluth down into its most basic elements: a city, a hill, a lake, trees. This started working a bit better.

An acrylic painting of a couple standing between birch trees at the top of a hill covered with evergreen trees that overlooks a lake so huge that the water goes to the horizon on a winter day with a clear blue sky.

Note: For each query, the program generates four outputs. For the examples here, I have chosen the output that best matched what I wanted.

The program allows you to imitate a specific painting medium, such as oil or acrylic, but you can also create an image in the style of a particular artist, like Edward Hopper.

An Edward Hopper style painting of a man walking down a steep street lined with brick houses towards a huge lake.

I tried adding in more specific elements to see if that would give the outputs a better sense of place.

An oil painting of a man biking down a steep city street at sunset in a city on a hill that overlooks a huge lake with one long cargo ship on the water.

Changing just a few elements of the description often resulted in a completely different output.

An oil painting of a boy biking at sunset down a hill in a city that overlooks a large lake with a large cargo ship on the horizon.

At some point, I realized that specifying the color of the ship improved the Duluthiness of the results dramatically.

A watercolor painting of a couple standing between maple, asp and birch trees with red, yellow and orange leaves on a bright fall day at the top of a hill that overlooks a huge lake with one red cargo ship on the water.

The challenge was keeping the query manageable while to trying to invoke specific places, like Park Point.

A pointillist painting of woman running along the empty sandy beach of a large lake on clear summer day with a city on a long hill behind her and a large red cargo ship on the water of the lake.

In addition to artwork, one could potentially use the program to create fake historical photos like a trained black bear skiing at Chester Bowl …

A 1940s black and white photograph of a black bear skiing off a ski jump and over a small frozen river as a crowd watches.

… or to generate images that mimic popular Perfect Duluth Day posts.

A photo of a wolf riding on the back of a moose with a loon on each antler walking across a shallow lake surrounded by birch and pine trees on a clear autumn day.

But these images, while amusing, don’t match the prompts exactly and aren’t particularly photorealistic. In addition to functional issues like not knowing what a loon is, the program tries to prevent potential misuse by scrambling any human faces in the image.

A better use might be to quickly generate images that show possible futures. For example, what downtown Duluth might look like if Essentia keeps expanding.

A synthwave-style image of downtown buildings, with people walking between the buildings across enclosed glass bridges that hang over an empty brick street, digital art.

Of course, paintings and photographs aren’t the only possible outputs. The program will also attempt to generate an image for any object you describe.

A red lake freighter inside of a snow globe.

Most of my queries, however, remain directed toward trying to create some Duluth art for my wall, like this attempt at a watercolor painting of a bridge over the Lester River.

A watercolor painting of an arched brown stone bridge over a stream, with large grey rocks on both sides of the water and autumn trees next to the rocks.

None of these AI-generated images are quite as nice as the print that I found in the Lincoln Park shop, but I remain hopeful that something incredible is just one well-formulated query away.

If you think you know what that query might be, feel free to put it in the comments and if I still have some credits left, I’ll give it a try and post the result.



about 2 years ago

This is both really cool and quite creepy. Is Duluth just a set of descriptors, like "very large lake"? Would it feel odd to not have an artist name/association when you look at the image on your wall?

Matthew James

about 2 years ago

I suppose Duluth is something more, because "very large lake" got a bit close but not quite there. I think this might be like the early days of photography, when a lot of people said a photo couldn't be art because you just pressed a button. Then people started to generally agree the art was in how and when you pushed the button. By analogy, the art here would be in how you formulate the query. I have no idea how the program made these images (I couldn't build a camera either), but I started by imagining what I wanted and it's about what I got. That might be enough for me to feel like it's my own work when I put one on my wall.

Paul Lundgren

about 2 years ago

Can we get an AI interpretation of the style of painter Adam Swanson? Something like: "A penguin and a robot in a canoe floating in a lake of bicycles with a row of wind turbines on a hill in the background." 

Or maybe just describe the physical characteristics of Bob Dylan and see what pops up? Something like: "A thin elderly man with wild and wavy greying black hair and a pencil-thin mustache wearing a white shirt under a black sport coat."

"Two giant, bloody banjos fighting like dinosaurs," also comes to mind as a query.

Matthew James

about 2 years ago

Since no other requests have come in, I will grant all three wishes. I don't think you will be getting exactly what you wanted, but isn't that always the case with wishes?

First, a penguin and a robot in a canoe floating in a lake of bicycles with a row of wind turbines on a hill in the background, in the style of Adam Swanson.

Matthew James

about 2 years ago

Next ... A thin elderly man with wild and wavy greying black hair and a pencil-thin mustache wearing a white shirt under a black sport coat.

Matthew James

about 2 years ago

This last one required some modification to get around the rather sensitive filters that prevent asking for images that might result in depictions of violence, so I changed that query to...

two giant red banjos facing each other like dinosaurs

I think the result might be more, "two giant red dinosaurs facing each other like banjos," but I like it.

Leave a Comment

Only registered members can post a comment , Login / Register Here

Read previous post:
Selective Focus: Burdock Ceramics

Burdock Ceramics is the pottery duo of Duluth artists Rita Morris and Barry Sands. Their pieces are hand thrown and...