Apparently the far right lunatic fringe is now considered mainstream.

I don't know about PDD-in-general, especially since it tends to be a rather loose affiliation of individuals  and not a monolithic entity, but I'm all for being a harsh critic of the overpriced thin on content out-of-state paper masquerading as something local and relevant.

Duluth News Tribune tries to be too many things.

If I were DNT CEO ...

...I'd fix pages to a nice seo url and not require login, EVER.


...I'd then stop doing the half-assed video broadcast in their own player and release it to a real video service that is widely distributed or get rid of it altogether. Or make it a reality show with scripts and bad camera shaking and everything. Stop the dead air! Make a morning show? Interview people? Have scenes from plays that around town? 


...I'd then let each staff member do whatever they wanted to help the newspaper for a 4 hour block in a 2 week period. Let them interview whoever they want. Following passions is sorely needed.




If all else fails I will just go the route they are already going and push an ALL Grandma's bragbook format. Coupons, cute kids, cuter dogs! "Oh that is Dorothy's daughter swimming with dolphins, isn't that cute?"

Think they may have confused DCB with PDD.

"...I'd then let each staff member do whatever they wanted to help the newspaper for a 4 hour block in a 2 week period. Let them interview whoever they want. Following passions is sorely needed."

How very Google of you.

I would hope that they meant to say PDD has found a niche as a mainstream critic of the online Duluth News Tribune.

Considering all the vitriol spewed at the DNT on this website (Oh my God, you endorsed McCain! You bastards!) it's amusing to see folks here suddenly backpedaling.

When your protest is, "That's not all we do!" that sounds like backpedaling to me. Why act like you're ashamed of it? Be proud! Put it in the banner, "PDD, the DNT whacker!"
Otherwise, if you can come up with nine better words to describe PDD than "harsh online critic of the mainstream Duluth News Tribune," have at it. Maybe you should have a contest.

To the Duluth News Tribune:

I like when newspapers have links to their past coverage on a topic beneath the current article.  That way it's easier to put the new news into context (this is a good time to temporarily suspend the fee for related archived articles).

When I email someone a link to an article it helps if they don't have to create a login to read that one article.  I like how the login requirements on some papers don't kick in until after a few page views.

Also, whenever I try to print an article, even when I use the print function, the right side of all the lines gets cut off.  This doesn't happen with other papers.  

The website feels cluttered and redundant.  It seems like a computer generated mismash.  The gold standard for newspaper websites is the NY Times (obviously a bigger market), but the layout could be emulated.  I want the DNT for news about Duluth, but when I click on "Duluth" all I get is random pictures from articles weeks ago and blog posts. Think Zen.

Even on a tight budget I'd like to see some investigative reporting every once in a while to show us you're on the side of citizens.  For a great example of this look to the Star Tribune, who even while in bankruptcy, has done excellent reporting on the Gang Strike Task Force.

Slow news day?  Some papers reprint articles or well-written columns from the distant past that are either interesting historically or shed a different light on the issues of the day.  I would love to open the DNT and learn more about this town's storied past.

I like newspapers that use their facilities to be the arbitrator of a public debate.  It is not a newspapers job to be an echo chamber to repeat mistruths stated by those who have an agenda or are mistaken.  Use your resources to fact check and then set the record straight.  All is not relative.

What is the Mayor doing? What happened at the city council meeting?  What is Oberstar trying to do for NE Minnesota through his committee chairmanship?  How will the actions of the MN legislature, or of the governor effect Duluth? Maybe these questions could get some in depth analysis in the paper.

The NY Times Sunday wrote an explosive article about water pollution Sunday and released the violation data obtained through the Freedom of Information Act from the EPA's of all 50 states.   Has the DNT looked at this data to see who is polluting Lake Superior? Have you called North Shore Mining for comment?  Anybody see a story somewhere here?

Hopefully, this comes across as constructive and not harsh. Any other critics out there feeling constructive?

I personally have never thought that the main appeal of PDD is the snark and criticism, if anything it's the opposite.

I visit the site to see what's going on in the community, be it cultural events, news (yes, some that may go unreported in the 'mainstream' press) and the occasional spirited discussion about topics such as this.

However, if PDD was *all* stuff like this, I'd never visit, much as I do not visit DCB, which IMHO is too much negativity and griping, and not enough doing something to improve the community.

I am back to the headline "MaCain is Northland Pick for the Next Pres".

How can you point a finger at a blog like this after the political propaganda that was printed before the prez race.

WoW

Peace

PS Free speech is just that and everybody has the right to the truth no matter what your media says.

Just piping in to say I come to PDD for interesting, off-beat, creative, snarky things about my community.

I think the real issue with the article might be that dusu.com is looking at a similar audience - though what I've seen, it's a bit boring. PDD's comments section is what makes this website THE go-to community webby - snark and all!

Hey I hear that other blog that's a "harsh critic" of everything that's good and beautiful about Duluth has been foaming at the mouth all month, and especially since the primary, at the prospect of "Homos" and "Carpet Munchers" taking over the city of Duluth. It's hilarious, watching these crazies implode so publicly.